The recent surge in gold prices has drawn considerable attention to gold stock ETFs, highlighting a trend where funds are being fervently tradedNotably, the Huaxia Fund's gold stock ETF has become a focal point, experiencing a three-day rally capped at its trading limit, leading to a premium exceeding 30%. This phenomenon is directly tied to the ongoing volatility and phenomenal increases in international gold prices, which have reached unprecedented heights.

As of early April, gold futures on the New York Mercantile Exchange (COMEX) soared past $2,300 per ounce, a thrilling milestone that has rippled through the financial marketsFollowing closely, gold in London spot trading also breached the same price threshold shortly afterThis bullish market sentiment has set the stage for gold stock ETFs to thrive, as evidenced by their performance amidst the influx of capital and trading activities stimulated by rising gold prices.

On April 3rd, the Huaxia Fund’s gold stock ETF opened an hour late due to overwhelming trading activity that led to a dramatic price spike

Advertisements

This product has not only hit the trading ceiling on consecutive days but has also cemented its position as a record-holder in premium rates, achieving a remarkable 30%. In contrast, the Yongying Fund’s gold stock ETF, which tracks the same index, exhibited a much more subdued performance with a 4.29% increase and a mere 0.72% premiumThe stark difference in their performance can be attributed to various market dynamics at play.

The recent trends in gold prices can be partly explained by the broader economic conditions and investor behaviorsThe historical context of rising gold prices is often related to global market instability or inflation fears, as seen during times of financial uncertaintyGold has consistently been viewed as a safe-haven asset; thus, its purchase tends to increase when investors feel uneasy about stock market performance or geopolitical tensions.

Uniquely, the current gold stock ETF landscape boasts a total of 16 gold-themed ETFs in the market, with a majority—14 to be precise—operating under the Shanghai Gold Exchange’s “gold spot contracts,” contributing to their pricing dynamics

Advertisements

However, gold stock ETFs, specifically those that directly target stock indices, are relatively rareOnly two major names, Huaxia and Yongying Funds, have ETFs actively trading in this niche since their recent approval to invest in gold stock indices in October 2023.

In comparison with ETFs linked to physical gold spot contracts, gold stock ETFs demonstrate higher volatility and potential for returnsData shows that in the last three years, the beta for gold stocks, against physical gold, was approximately 1.3, and in bullish market segments, this number rises to 1.5, displaying their greater elasticity in price movements.

As of April 3rd, gold-themed ETFs showed annual price increases primarily between 10% and 12%, with only two notable gold stock ETFs exhibiting gains beyond 20%. The Yongying gold stock ETF, since its inception, has yielded a 28.17% return, while the Huaxia variant has outstripped this significantly with an extraordinary 79.49% increase

Advertisements

The Huaxia gold stock ETF was established on January 11 of this year, and despite being newer than the Yongying ETF, it has rapidly gained traction in investor interest.

The meteoric rise of Huaxia’s ETF, which surged by 47.32% from March 28 to April 3, is indicative of its popularity driven by speculative trading, despite its relatively smaller size—with only 39.13 million shares currently available equating to a fund size of 56.89 million yuanThis stark increase highlights the powerful role of investor sentiment in ETF performance.

While the high upswing of Huaxia's ETF has attracted excitement, it also comes with associated risksIts premium rate as of April 3 culminated at an alarming 30.03%, raising concerns among fund managers who promptly issued alerts to investors about potential risks associated with entering at such high valuationsSuch price spikes typically lead to eventual corrections as market enthusiasm wanes and arbitrage opportunities arise.

Interestingly, the particular resilience of Huaxia's gold stock ETF against typical retraction phenomena may be explained by a combination of factors

• Strengthening Cooperation for Global Energy Transition
• Rising Energy Prices and Dollar Interest Rate Hikes
• Differences in Inflation Between China and the United States
• Cross-Border ETFs Hit a Sudden Brake!
• Global Energy Crisis: Soaring Coal Prices

Beyond speculative investment motives stemming from anticipated gold price increases, the structural composition of the ETF plays a crucial roleThe asset pool not only encompasses A-share listed companies but also includes gold equities from Hong Kong, further diversifying its exposureDue to market holidays on March 29 and April 1 in Hong Kong, exchanges were halted, limiting the options for stock exchanges in the interimThis factor potentially creates a tighter market and contributes to a sustained premium as the trading environment adjusts.

As the equity market reacts to anticipated gold price trends, an upward shift in gold prices invariably leads to increased valuation of gold stocks—creating what is known as a "Davis Double," where both the underlying commodity and its respective stocks rise simultaneously.

Take Shandong Gold as a prime example: the company reported that the first three quarters of 2023 showed a net profit that exceeds the entirety of their 2022 earnings by over 94.12%. Forecasts suggest that their next reported net profits will range between 2 to 2.5 billion yuan, translating into sizable growth fueled by escalating gold prices.

While the gold industry in China boasts numerous listed companies, only a handful are large-scale mining operations

As per the statistics from 2022, only two companies produced over 30 tons of gold—Zijin Mining and Shandong Gold—while others like Zhaojin Mining, Zhongjin Gold, and Chifeng Gold hovered between 10 to 30 tons, with most producing far below that threshold.

Despite the skeptical outlook for gold's future resistance beyond the $2,300 threshold, analysts remain optimistic regarding ongoing gold price trendsTianfeng Securities posits that barring any inflation adjustments, gold could reach upwards of $2,400 per ounceHistorical patterns suggest that the profitability of gold firms often lag behind the commodity's performance; hence, there is a phase of divergence between equity and commodity marketsHowever, as gold prices remain on an uptrend, gold stocks can anticipate more immediate profit realizations as their financial health improves.

Nonetheless, as gold prices surged above $2,300, it faced resistance and subsequently retraced back to the $2,300 mark

Market perspectives on the Federal Reserve's interest rate decisions also inject uncertainty, presenting a juxtaposition in market dynamics—strong support for gold based on anticipated rate cuts while the looming uncertainty may prompt short-term corrections.

In the backdrop of this volatile market, significant players such as hedge funds have certainly profited from these movementsThe Huaxia Gold Stock ETF's recent trajectory benefits those invested, particularly institutions that hold a considerable share of the product—accounting for nearly 57.79% of the entirety of sharesFor instance, Shanghai Dongzheng Futures holds the largest share—20 million units—making it poised to gather substantial returns, having already accumulated around 14 million yuan in profits.

In contrast, the Yongying ETF showcases a different shareholder composition, where a notable count of hedge and private equity funds has reduced dramatically over time

It’s interesting that institutional holdings increased considerably from an initial 16.84% to over 60.29% within a short six monthsThis indicates a shift in investment strategies as mainstream brokers increasingly align with gold-themed avenues.

It’s worth mentioning that among the notable institutional investors is Bridgewater Associates, a hedge fund known for its strategiesSince early 2022, their presence in top holders for several gold ETFs has been apparent, tapping into the resurgence of gold prices as a hedge against market instabilityAs of year-end 2023, various funds within Bridgewater’s portfolio featured among top holders in multiple products, showcasing their strategic foresight amid challenging market conditions.

With their holdings across numerous ETFs amounting to a current market value of approximately 980 million yuan—up from 880 million yuan—Bridgewater capitalized on the recent upward trajectory of these funds significantly